Review by: Robert Parker
Wine Advocate: Issue 145, February 2003
Rating: 94 POINTS

The 2000 Chateauneuf du Pape La Reserve Secrete was fashioned from the estate's finest parcels. Part of the cuvee was aged 12 months in new oak and the remainder in foudre. The actual composition is a surprising 60% Syrah and 40% Grenache. It is tempting to think this is an internationally-styled effort, but it does not taste like a soulless international blend. It reveals all the typicity of Provence as well as Chateauneuf du Pape in its sweet kirsch liqueur and blackberry-scented nose. Full-bodied, with low acidity, extraordinary purity and ripeness, an opaque purple color, and deep, chewy flavors revealing only a hint of new oak's vanilla/toast character, this effort exhibits great presence on the palate, loads of glycerin and extract, as well as a 45+ second finish. It is surprisingly harmonious, with the alcohol, tannin, acidity, and wood beautifully integrated. While this 2000 already has a certain accessibility, there is also a fabulous upside potential.

Review by: Per-Henrik Mansson
Wine Spectator: Issue August 31, 2003
Rating: 97 POINTS
Drink now - 2025

Masterful wine. Stunning quality from start to finish in this full-bodied, elegant and refined red. Dark in color, massively tannic, but all the parts are smooth and interlock beautifully, from the sweet black fruit and slightly spicy, mocha and coffee aromas to the (above all) velvety texture that caresses the palate and leaves an ethereal sense of greatness on the long finish. One for now, but also one for the cellar. Drink now through 2025. 465 cases made.